Protein enzymes are highly efficient catalysts that exhibit adaptability and selectivity under diverse biological conditions. In some organisms, such as bacteria, structurally similar enzymes, for instance, shikimate kinase (SK) and adenylate kinase (AK), coexist and act on chemically related ligands. This raises the question of whether these enzymes can accommodate and potentially react with each other’s ligands. In this study, we investigate the stability of non-cognate ligand binding in SK and explore whether external electric fields (EFs) can modulate this interaction, leading to cross-reactivity in SK. Using molecular dynamics simulations, we assess the structural integrity of SK and the binding behavior of ATP and AMP under EF-off and EF-on cases. Our results show that EFs enhance protein structure stability, stabilize non-cognate ligands in the binding pocket, and reduce local energetic frustration near the R116 residue located in the binding site. In addition to this, dimensionality reduction analyses reveal that EFs induce more coherent protein motions and reduce the number of metastable states. Together, these findings suggest that external EFs can reshape enzyme–ligand interactions and may serve as a tool to modulate enzymatic specificity and functional promiscuity. Thus, we provide computational evidence that supports the concept of using an EF as a tunable parameter in enzyme engineering and synthetic biology. However, further experimental investigation would be valuable to assess the reliability of our computational predictions.