Spending time in nature has many benefits for older individuals’ health and well-being and is often closely tied to personal identity. As individuals age, their activity spaces typically become more geographically limited to areas near their homes. Therefore, having access to nearby nature environments is crucial for maintaining their habits of engaging with nature. This study employs a mixed-methods approach, combining survey data and interviews with older adults in two Swedish municipalities, to explore what proximity to nature means to them and how it influences their relocation decisions. The findings highlight that the relationship between individuals and nature environments can be lifelong and deeply embedded in their identity; something they wish to preserve in later life. However, various individual and societal constraints can complicate the ability to prioritise proximity to nature when moving. We argue that access to nature for older adults should be more prominently considered in policy planning, as it is currently underrepresented. It is essential to provide housing options with nature nearby, whether individuals choose to age in place or relocate to improve access to other amenities.